Download FREE Practo app
Get ₹200 HealthCash
Kidney stone
Recently I changed my Schwabe germany berberis vulgaris and Hydrangea Arborescens to Indian one but the Indian one is not providing relief properly as the last one caused almost no problems to me and privided me relief hence should I increase the dosage of berberis to 20 drops for it to work properly or again buy the german one and dispose these Indian schwabe berberis and hydrangea. I have one stone in right kidney which is of 14 mm and another in left which is of 4 mm. I am already thanking you for your reply and appreciate that you replied
Answers (35)
Get your queries answered instantly with Care AI FREE
20000+ health queries resolved in last month
Back to German
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Didn't find the answer you are looking for?
Talk to experienced doctor online and get your health questions answered in just 5 minutes.
+129
See, using medicines like this will not help, they will not cure the problem. For this you need to take proper consulatation and need to give complete and detailed case, so that we can come up with your individualized medicine.
Next Steps
feel free to consult me.
Health Tips
Do not take medicines on your own. Consultation doctor here or near by!
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
So go back on german.
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Consult online
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello Practo User, use homoeopathic medications for your problem to get Instant and effective results.Its Curable, no need to worry about. Homoeopathic medicines plays Excellent role to treat Such problems in a hollistic way without any side effect.I suggest you to message me your complete history in private chat with all reports & details & Consult Online through Practo. I will guide you for holistic & effective Results with homoeopathy ! Take care !! Best Regards:)
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
What I suggest is you need not to self medicate with homoeopathic mother tinctures.
For such type of complaints you are required to take proper holistic healing through homoeopathy.
Also proper diet is necessary along with medicine.
Recurrence of kidney stones can be prevented with proper homoeopathic medicines.
Also it is not that one company medicine is good or bad than the other.
It is the appropriate treatment that you required.
Hence case taking is must
You can consult me online
Seven eight seven four seven two three seven one one
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Stone size is the most important factor
A 14 mm stone (right kidney) is quite large and may not pass with medicines alone
A 4 mm stone (left kidney) can usually pass with proper treatment
About changing brands / dosage
Increasing the dose of Berberis vulgaris to 20 drops will not significantly improve results
The issue is not mainly the brand (German vs Indian), but the size and nature of the stone
Avoid self-adjusting medicines
Do not frequently change brands or increase doses on your own
It can lead to unpredictable results and delay proper management
Medicines like Berberis vulgaris and Hydrangea arborescens can help in:
Reducing pain
Assisting passage of smaller stones
But they are supportive, not a guaranteed solution for large stones
Homeopathy can support and prevent recurrence, but for a large 14 mm stone, a combined approach with a urologist is strongly recommended.
Next Steps
Consult a urologist for the 14 mm stone (procedures like lithotripsy may be required)
Continue medical management for the smaller stone under supervision
Health Tips
Drink plenty of water (3–4 liters/day unless restricted)
When to seek urgent care
Severe pain
Vomiting
Fever
Difficulty passing urine
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
I am not contradicting you but please don't medicate yourself without proper consultation.
Next Steps
took proper consultation
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello, thanks for sharing your detailed concern.
Aapka case samajh aa raha hai — aapko right kidney me around 14 mm ka stone hai aur left side me 4 mm ka stone present hai. Aapne German (Dr. Reckeweg/Schwabe Germany) medicines se relief feel kiya tha, lekin Indian formulation se utna expected relief nahi mil raha.
Sabse important baat ye hai ki 14 mm stone ka size kaafi bada hota hai, jo usually medicines se easily pass nahi hota. Isliye sirf drops ki quantity badha dena (jaise 20 drops) bina proper assessment ke advisable nahi hai.
Homeopathy me medicine ka effect sirf brand par depend nahi karta, balki proper selection, potency aur individual symptoms par depend karta hai. Kabhi-kabhi dose badhane se benefit ke bajaye aggravation bhi ho sakta hai.
Aapke case me:
4 mm stone (left kidney) pass ho sakta hai with proper management
14 mm stone (right kidney) needs careful monitoring and may require urological opinion
👉 Is stage par best approach ye rahega ki:
Recent USG/KUB report ke basis par reassessment kiya jaye.
Symptoms (pain, burning, urine flow) ke according proper remedy decide ki jaye
Self dose increase karne se bachein
Next Steps
👉 Accurate guidance aur safe treatment ke liye personalised consultation bahut zaroori hai.
👉 Aap consult karke apne case ke liye customised homeopathic plan le sakte hain for faster aur better relief.
Health Tips
👉 Roz 3–4 litre pani piyen, taaki stone naturally flush hone me help mile.
👉 Zyada namak, oily aur junk food avoid karein, aur diet me nimbu pani/shikanji include karein.
👉 Regular urine pass karein, urine ko rok kar na rakhein aur light physical activity maintain karein.
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your query.
A 14 mm renal stone (right kidney) is relatively large and may not respond reliably to medicines alone, whereas a 4 mm stone (left side) is comparatively small and may pass with supportive treatment.
Regarding your concern:
• Simply increasing the dose of Berberis Vulgaris (e.g., 20 drops) is not advisable without proper guidance, as more quantity does not necessarily improve effectiveness in homoeopathy.
• The difference you are experiencing is not always due to Indian vs German preparation alone, but can also depend on potency, repetition, and individual response.
• Self-adjusting multiple remedies (Berberis Vulgaris, Hydrangea) may lead to inconsistent results.
At this stage, the priority should be:
• Proper assessment of stone size, location, and symptoms
• Monitoring for obstruction or complications
• Timely opinion from a urologist, especially for the 14 mm stone
Supportive measures:
• Adequate hydration
• Watch for symptoms like severe pain, vomiting, fever, or urinary difficulty
For homoeopathic management, a well-individualized prescription (rather than dose escalation or brand change) is more appropriate.
Wishing you good health.
Regards,
Dr. Kiran Mate(healthrisebydrkiran)
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Instead of taking random suggestions I suggest taking proper treatment in homoeopathy.
As it can give you permanent cure instead of temporary relief.
You can contact me on
Nine four zero nine three seven two six zero zero
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Consult homeopathy physician
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
I understand your concern, and itâs good that you are observing your response to medicines carefully.
You are currently taking Berberis vulgaris and Hydrangea arborescens for kidney stones. These medicines are commonly used, but in homeopathy, results do not depend only on the brand or increasing the dosage.
Increasing the dose (like 20 drops) on your own is not advisable, especially in a case like yours where:
One stone is 14 mm (quite large) but quite possible in homeopathy for treatment
Another is 4 mm
A 14 mm stone is generally difficult to pass naturally and requires careful monitoring and individualized treatment. in my experience i have seen with more than 14mm also reduced size and pased away ,Simply changing brand or increasing dosage may not give the desired results and can delay proper management.
Regarding German vs Indian medicines:
Sometimes patients feel better with certain preparations, but the core issue is selecting the right remedy, potency, and repetition based on your total symptoms, not just the medicine name.
What should be done ideally:
Proper case evaluation (pain pattern, urine symptoms, constitution)
Selection of the most suitable remedy (may or may not be the same medicines)
Correct potency and dosage
Regular follow-up to monitor stone movement
With the right approach, homeopathy can:
Help reduce pain and burning
Support gradual passage of smaller stones
Prevent recurrence
Improve kidney function overall
please check our google reviews also for such cases.and testimonials on instagram and facebook
you can contact me directly for consutation
Regards
Dr jyoti Kadkol
Health Global Homoeopathy, Vijaynagar, Bangalore
www.healthglobalclinics.com
Answered
Flag this answer
2/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
It will be easily cured with my treatment permanently
Consult me via practo
Will prescribe the complete treatment
Regards
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Consult an expert Homeopathic physician asap.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello.
The size of the stone are bigger to pass through urine.
Therr are medicine that will help you either dissolve or break it for easy passage of the stone.
Self medication or changing your doses is not advised as the progress and the improvement/present condition should mlbe recorded before any furtyer medication.
Need more details so that i can help you with your condition.
Do not worry on medicine part we are here to help.
Next Steps
Kindly connect
Health Tips
Maintain hydration.
Do not hold up your urine.
No alcohol.
Answered
Flag this answer
2/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
A 14 mm stone is large for Kidney stones and may not pass easily with medicines alone.Changing brands may cause slight variation, but increasing dose on your own is not advisable it won’t necessarily improve results and may disturb the response.
Next Steps
You can contact me for proper treatment on whatsapp via 708302736nine
Health Tips
Don’t hold urine. Drink 3–4 litres water daily
Answered
Flag this answer
2/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
There's excellent homoeopathic medicine for renal stone.
You will get permanent cure with homoeopathic constitutional medicine because I had cure many similar cases.
Need more details for proper treatment and guidance.
Next Steps
Kindly consult me on practo online or calling.
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hi Practo user
A homoeopathic treatment will give you best results naturally
You can easily take an online consultation for personalised treatment
Or click on the calling option over my profile on Practo
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Basically there's no mean to differentiate between indian and German mode,,both acts equally but,yes if expecting anything like that,then try to consult online and with a proper case taking your issue will be resolved definitely And you will be more satisfied then..And if you talk about doses it should not be increased without guidance..... don't worry renal stone is not a big deal for homoeopathy...Stay healthy and safe 👍🏻😊...
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Need detail case taking for it you can consult me on instant consult practo or 916702500one for detail
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello,
Thank you for sharing your concern. I understand that you experienced better relief with the German preparation as compared to the Indian one.
In cases of kidney stones, medicines like Berberis vulgaris and Hydrangea arborescens can be helpful, but the response may vary depending on the quality of the medicine, individual body response, and proper case selection. If you were getting better results with the German medicine, you may consider continuing the same for consistency.
However, increasing the dosage on your own (such as taking 20 drops) is not advisable without proper guidance, especially when you have a 14 mm stone in the right kidney and a 4 mm stone in the left kidney. A 14 mm stone is quite significant and requires a carefully planned and monitored treatment approach.
I would suggest proper case evaluation before making any changes, so that the treatment can be adjusted according to your condition and response.
I have successfully treated many patients with kidney stones and have good clinical experience in managing such cases.
📲 You can contact me online through chat for detailed consultation and personalized treatment guidance. I will be happy to assist you.
Answered
Flag this answer
3/3 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Need to check current USG( KUB ). Then prescription will go on further.
Next Steps
check current status
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Consultant through online, i will make sure you will get out of renal calculi
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello Practo user
It's a myth. It is not possible whether german medicine gives relief and Indian not. Consult online for proper guidance
Answered
Flag this answer
1/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Hello
You need a doctor for proper treatment there many other remedies in homoeopathy for stone. 14mm is a big size
You should consider the seriousness and consult a doctor not thinking about brands and dose self medicating
Answered
Flag this answer
1/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Sometimes its because of the brand also
I will one powder i suggest u to take it with curd within 05 days the stone will come out u will not have issues
I had previous one pateint with 6mm stone it came out within 6days the stone
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
You are looking at it wrongly.
Are you looking for relief or cure.
No matter german or Indian if the medicine is relieving the complaints temporarily than it is not proper homoeopathic treatment.
Better take proper homoeopathic treatment.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/2 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
●𝗬𝗲𝘀 𝗶𝘁 𝗰𝗮𝗻 𝗯𝗲 𝗽𝗲𝗿𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗹𝘆 𝗰𝘂𝗿𝗲𝗱 𝘄𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗛𝗼𝗺𝗲𝗼𝗽𝗮𝘁𝗵𝘆 𝗧𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁 .
●𝗩𝗲𝗿𝘆 𝗲𝗳𝗳𝗲𝗰𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲 𝗺𝗲𝗱𝗶𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗲𝘀 𝗮𝗿𝗲 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗶𝗻 𝗛𝗼𝗺𝗲𝗼𝗽𝗮𝘁𝗵𝗶𝗰
●𝗪𝗶𝘁𝗵 𝗺𝘆 𝘁𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁 𝗼𝗳 1.5 𝗺𝗼𝗻𝘁𝗵 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝘄𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗴𝗲𝘁 𝗽𝗲𝗿𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗲𝗻𝘁 𝗿𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗲𝗳.
●𝗪𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗽𝗿𝗲𝘀𝗰𝗿𝗶𝗯𝗲 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗽𝗹𝗲𝘁𝗲 𝘁𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁.
●𝗬𝗼𝘂 𝗰𝗮𝗻 𝗰𝗼𝗻𝘀𝘂𝗹𝘁 𝗺𝗲 𝗻𝗼𝘄 𝘁𝗵𝗿𝗼𝘂𝗴𝗵 𝗼𝗻𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗲 𝗪𝗮𝗿𝗺 𝗿𝗲𝗴𝗮𝗿𝗱𝘀.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Sameeksha Hemant Patil
Homoeopath
3 yrs exp
Nashik
Listen Did Someone pescribe you those medicine. If not plz first Consult me online through practo.Don't Self medicate.
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Need to check USG for exact location of stone, 14 mm needs to be supervised yet possible to get it out with medications
Next Steps
contact for online consultation, medicine can be couriered. nine eight six nine double one three four three four.
Health Tips
Drink 3L of water atleast
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Sayyed Atiya Fatema
Homoeopath
20 yrs exp
Hyderabad
The efficacy whether it is German or Indian is the same. 4 mm can be easily dissolved but the size 14 mm is big size stones where we can work on size reduction however it not only depends on the size but position of the stone. If you are not opting for surgery you can try a phased reduction program. There is a call button on our practo you can contact us on heal health homeopathy.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Neelima Bisai
Homoeopath
3 yrs exp
Bangalore
Pls consult a homoeopathic physician asap
Answered
Flag this answer
1/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Vishalkumar Dhulabhai Parmar
Homoeopath
3 yrs exp
Anand
Would be glad to help you manage this properly. Please book an online consultation with me through my profile. We can review your recent USG reports in detail, discuss your specific symptoms, and tailor a precise and effective treatment plan to help you pass these stones safely.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Madhu Kabadge
Homoeopath
12 yrs exp
Pune
Reliving of symptoms is not cure . It's matter of correct medicines and correct doses . For further queries and treatment consult through practo.
Answered
Flag this answer
0/1 people found this helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Articles you may like
Disclaimer : The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.
The question asked on this page is a free question. You can ask a free health question by downloading the Practo app.
Articles you may like
Tell us what's troubling you
Tell us what's troubling you
Disclaimer : The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.