Download FREE Practo app
Get ₹200 HealthCash
Please suggest which one to go with
I have a fracture at the base of my fifth metatarsal, and the bone fragment has separated. Could you please let me know if this can be treated with a slab/cast or if surgery would be necessary?
Answers (9)
A separated fragment at the 5th metatarsal base usually needs surgical fixation (screw) for proper healing and to avoid non-union. Cast alone may not be enough if there is significant displacement. An orthopedic surgeon needs to evaluate your X-ray and decide.
Next Steps
Consult me on Practo or see an orthopedic surgeon in person soon.
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Didn't find the answer you are looking for?
Talk to experienced orthopedist online and get your health questions answered in just 5 minutes.
+192
Surgical treatment is better
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Based on the X-ray, this appears to be a displaced fracture at the base of the fifth metatarsal. While some fractures in this region can heal with a cast or boot, a displaced fracture may require surgical fixation to restore alignment, provide stable compression, and reduce the risk of delayed or non-union. The final decision depends on the exact fracture type, degree of displacement, and clinical examination.
Next Steps
I recommend consulting an Orthopaedic Surgeon at the earliest for a detailed assessment. Additional X-ray views or CT scan may be required before deciding the best treatment. If you would like me to review your X-rays in detail and discuss whether surgery is necessary in your case, you can also book an online consultation with me.
Health Tips
Until you are evaluated, avoid putting weight on the affected foot, keep it elevated, apply ice to reduce swelling, and use a below-knee splint or CAM boot if available. If pain, swelling, or deformity worsens, seek immediate medical attention.
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
This doesn’t look like a recent fracture?can I know when did this happen?
This needs fixation
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Go for surgery as it is quite displaced and may not heal with plaster
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Jakka Sri Vani
Orthopedist
8 yrs exp
Hyderabad
This is pseudo jones fracture , in Xray the fragment looks displaced , slab/ cast will not help in your case and may cause non union of the fracture ,surgery is best.
Health Tips
If it is a fresh fracture
Avoid weight bearing on the injured foot
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Rahul Kumar Pandey
Orthopedic surgeon
10 yrs exp
Lucknow
For your case surgical treatment is better than cast.
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Rakesh Kumar
Orthopedic surgeon
6 yrs exp
Coimbatore
Based on patient profile the decision of management has to be taken, ask the surgeon and get to know the pros and cons of both modalities, analyse the options and choose accordingly
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Dr. Prakhar Rastogi
Orthopedic Surgeon
6 yrs exp
Meerut
Hey ,
It is called jones fracture and it needs to be fixed . Can’t be managed conservatively with slab or cast as the fractured segment is displaced . If it would have been in displaced then we could have tried a conservative approach .
Answered
Flag this answer
Let others know if this answer was helpful
Was this answer helpful?
YES
NO
Articles you may like
Disclaimer : The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.
The question asked on this page is a free question. You can ask a free health question by downloading the Practo app.
Articles you may like
Tell us what's troubling you
Tell us what's troubling you
Disclaimer : The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.