I can offer general advice here, a proper diagnosis often requires a more thorough evaluation.
The recommendation to remove the existing implant and place a new one with a removable temporary cap is one possible approach (usually up to 3mos till implant is ready to receive permanent cap), often indicated by issues like infection or implant failure.
Alternative options might include
addressing the existing restoration (if feasible),
different implant techniques,
a fixed temporary restoration (depending on the situation),
dental bridge (involving adjacent teeth),
or a removable partial denture(to be removed every night)
Health Tips
Best advice can be given after checking the patient in person .
Consider having a detailed discussion with the dentist.
or could visit for a second opinion