Surgery for sure in my opinion looking at your age and long future ahead.
Bucket handle tear of.meniscus causes serious locking, clicking and pain. It has to be either repaired or partial meniscectomy has to be done.
ACL bony avulsion will cause instability. It is fixed with a screw or reconstruction done depending on size of the bony fragment.
Next Steps
These are done arthroscopically, which is a minimally invasive modality.
Health Tips
Go for surgery if you want a stable and reliable knee.