You feel odd because of the gum tissue color in the cap?. If that's your concern the only way out is doing a flap surgery where some gums can be grown over the tooth and a new crown replaced.
Next Steps
If upon smiling the pink color on the cap is not visible, you need not change it. Usually only 3-4 mm of white teeth is seen on smiling and exaggerated laughing.... so if that is the case you can keep the same cap.