The choice of going for surgery or conservative treatment entirely depends on multiple factors, like xray reading , Type of fracture, dominant side or non dominant side( in respect to need to return to activity.), Surgeons experience about that particular fracture treatment,

Medicine is not exact science there will be lots of options of treatment I diffrence come when their experience has shown good result in their hand Regardless all doctors want best for their patient regardless of method of treatment choose whom you trust . You can go to ten other doctors and get ten diffrent advise for distal radius as the treatment has multiple options

if you can show ur x ray some how you will get the exact answer