Download FREE Practo app
Get ₹200 HealthCash
Why Didn't work Methylphenidate
Why Methylphenidate Not Working for Me? I Can’t Take Atomoxetine
Hello doctors,
I was prescribed Methylphenidate, and it only worked on the first dose, first day. After that, there was no noticeable effect. I’ve tried increasing the dosage and also used both IR and ER versions, but still no improvement.
I also cannot take Atomoxetine due to side effects.
Can you please help me understand:
Why did it only work on the first day?
Why is it not working anymore even with higher doses?
What can I do to improve its effectiveness?
Not finding what you need? Ask Practo AI
FREE
Chat with Practo AI on Whatsapp
Didn't find the answer you are looking for?
Talk to experienced psychiatrist online and get your health questions answered in just 5 minutes.
Not finding what you need? Ask Practo AI
FREE
Chat with Practo AI on Whatsapp
The fact that methylphenidate worked well on the first day but quickly lost its effect is more common than it sounds. This phenomenon is sometimes referred to as a honeymoon responseâan initial burst of improvement due to novelty or placebo effect, followed by reduced sensitivity as your brain adapts. Methylphenidate acts by increasing dopamine and norepinephrine in specific brain areas, but if those neural circuits are already underfunctioning or desensitized, the medicine may feel flat or ineffective. Also, people with certain ADHD subtypes or coexisting conditions like anxiety or depression may not respond well to stimulant medications. Itâs not a sign of failureâit just means your brain chemistry may need a different approach.
Next Steps
First, avoid increasing the dose on your ownâit rarely helps and can lead to more side effects without real benefit. What you need now is a careful re-evaluation of your ADHD subtype and comorbid conditions (like emotional dysregulation, anxiety, or sleep disturbances). Other stimulant classes like amphetamines (e.g. lisdexamfetamine or dextroamphetamine) often work better for those who do not respond to methylphenidate. Non-stimulant options beyond atomoxetineâlike bupropion or even modafinilâmay also be explored with guidance. You should consult a psychiatrist experienced in adult ADHD who can guide medication titration, combination strategies, or behavioral interventions alongside pharmacotherapy.
Health Tips
Keep a daily symptom trackerâlog your sleep, focus, mood, anxiety, diet, and medication timing. Many subtle factors, including protein intake, caffeine, hydration, or poor sleep, can affect how these medicines work. Avoid high-sugar or carb-heavy meals before dosing. If anxiety is high, it can blunt the effectiveness of stimulants, so managing that first might be the key. Lastly, consider cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for executive dysfunctionâit works synergistically with medications and can help you function better even during medication gaps. Youâre not alone in this. ADHD management is rarely a straight lineâbut with the right strategy, you can feel focused and in control again.
Answered
1/1 people found this helpful
Not finding what you need? Ask Practo AI
FREE
Chat with Practo AI on Whatsapp
Articles you may like
Tell us what's troubling you
Disclaimer : The content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.