Hello, what you are experiencing is the classic triphasic course of Subacute Thyroiditis.
1. Is this
TSH spike normal?
Yes, it is common. After the initial 'hyper' phase (low TSH) where the gland leaks stored hormone, the
thyroid becomes temporarily 'exhausted' or depleted. This leads to a transient hypothyroid phase, where TSH rises significantly (in your case, to 16) while T4 levels drop. This phase typically occurs 2–4 months after the initial onset.
2. Should you test for Hashimoto's?
While Subacute Thyroiditis is usually triggered by a virus, it can occasionally unmask or overlap with Hashimoto’s. Given that your TSH doubled in just two weeks (from 8 to 16), it is reasonable to check your Anti-TPO and Anti-Tg antibody levels. If these are highly positive, it suggests an autoimmune component (Hashimoto's) rather than just a temporary post-viral inflammation.
3. Should you start medication?
With a TSH of 16 and borderline low T4, you have Overt Hypothyroidism.
If you are experiencing symptoms like extreme fatigue, cold intolerance, or brain fog, low-dose Levothyroxine is usually started to support you while the gland heals.
If you have no symptoms, some doctors prefer to wait and retest in 4 weeks, as this phase is often self-limiting.
Recommendation:
I suggest checking your Anti-TPO antibodies and repeating the TSH/Free T4 in 2–4 weeks. If you are feeling symptomatic now, please consult for a starting dose of thyroid supplementation. Most patients recover full function within 6–12 months, though about 10–15% may require long-term support.