Consulting a Surgeon is a must. You said lump is Benign, then there should be no cause of worry. This must be a Fibroadenoma. You also have to see if it has a relation with menses, in which case it may be Fibroadenosis. If Fibroadenoma, getting it removed and getting a Biopsy done is the best option. Scar etc, a well skilled Surgeon will manage.
Next Steps
Consult a Surgeon